Jump to content
Requiem

5 bands' catalogues you'd take to a desert island.

Recommended Posts

You've been condemned to many years on a desert island with no contact with the outside world. 

You are, however, permitted to choose the entire back catalogue (studio and live) of 5 bands to take with you. Rather than picking 5 favourite albums, who do you pick when it comes to 5 desert island back catalogues? Metal only.

The more albums the better because you're going to be there a long time. Variety is also important. Like GreyscaleDawn, I've re-edited this to include an alternative in brackets. 

Here is my list: 

 

1. Mayhem (11 releases) - This is the black metal aspect. They cover a surprising lot of ground in their career, and I have Dead, Maniac, EURONYMOUS (hail 666), and Hellhammer to keep the extreme side of things available. (Septicflesh)

2. Opeth (15 releases) - A huge wealth of great songs, atmospheres, sophistication and moods. There is an Opeth album for every occasion. (Paradise Lost)

3. Katatonia (c. 15 releases) - Probably the greatest band of all time, and their whole collection covers so much territory. (My Dying Bride)

4. Nightwish (13 releases) - I've loved this band from the start and I didn't want to be stuck on an island with just gents. The female vocals, luscious song structures and large number of releases makes this a shoe-in. (Theatre of Tragedy)

5. Black Sabbath (many) - I'm editing this to get rid of Maiden and include Sabbath because I really don't know what I was thinking when I first made this post. Easily in my top 5 bands. (Iron Maiden)

 

Which back catalogues, and why, would you take to your desert island? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yikes, that's tough. Very similar to the original "top five bands" question, I can't narrow it down that much without leaving lots of great stuff out. Plus you say "metal only", which means there's no way I can sneak in my King Crimson albums or my medieval polyphony.

If I was consigned to such a cruel fate this very morning, I'd grab Opeth, Katatonia, My Dying Bride, Death, and Swans (which the guards will have to pry out of my cold, dead hands, which will probably happen sooner rather than later if I spend too much time actually listening to Swans). I can't imagine going for years (or even months) without listening to some of this music, and not only are they all among my favorite groups, they've all got albums I have yet to really warm up to, which will ensure that I have at least a little bit of the stimulation of new discovery awaiting me. Also, can I bring wine? And face soap?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The idea of this is to consider how much great material any particular band has. For instance there's no way I would rate Iron Maiden or Nightwish in my top 5 when it comes to just their music, but if I have to choose a band's full back catalogue then they make the grade because they have so much music out that I find entertaining and there's less chance of listening to Iron Maiden's back catalogue compared to, say, Sentenced. Even though Iron Maiden always kind of sound the same. Hmm, didn't think of that. 

I also didn't want five funeral doom bands, for instance, because that would make my time on the island a real downer. I want a mx - music for all occasions, such as building a tree house, collecting coconuts, sitting and reflecting on my past life, yearning for hot chicks, training the monkey butlers. Something for all moods. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is too damn hard.. there are too many ways to go about at it. I also added one potential option to replace what i chose. Things like this really in a way annoy the fuck out of me, the very thought of being limited musically like that sounds like an absolute nightmare. Also no matter what i would choose, i would feel bad about all the things i excluded. :D 

 

Vader. Pure aggrenaline oozing kickass band that has been often on my playlist for years. Some of the best covers in metal. (Krisiun)

Paradise Lost. One of my all time favourite bands with good variety in albums. Theres something for every situation. (Anathema)

Rhapsody. One of those bands that i listen to sometimes even if not my usual stuff, never fails to bring a smile on my face. (Nightwish)

Megadeth. When i was a teen, there was always a battle Metallica vs. Megadeth. I always loved both but Megadeth has my most loved songs from the duo. (Testament)

Hypocrisy. I´ve been listening to it regularily since the 90s, wouldn´t know how to be without it either. (Arch enemy)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, GrayscaleDawn said:

This is too damn hard.. there are too many ways to go about at it. I also added one potential option to replace what i chose. Things like this really in a way annoy the fuck out of me, the very thought of being limited musically like that sounds like an absolute nightmare. Also no matter what i would choose, i would feel bad about all the things i excluded. :D 

 

Vader. Pure aggrenaline oozing kickass band that has been often on my playlist for years. Some of the best covers in metal. (Krisiun)

Paradise Lost. One of my all time favourite bands with good variety in albums. Theres something for every situation. (Anathema)

Rhapsody. One of those bands that i listen to sometimes even if not my usual stuff, never fails to bring a smile on my face. (Nightwish)

Megadeth. When i was a teen, there was always a battle Metallica vs. Megadeth. I always loved both but Megadeth has my most loved songs from the duo. (Testament)

Hypocrisy. I´ve been listening to it regularily since the 90s, wouldn´t know how to be without it either. (Arch enemy)

Firstly, for the Paradise Lost reference I want to shake your hand, sir. i tip my cap to you. 

Secondly, great list. I love Rhapsody too, which I could never imagine doing in my younger years. Luca Turilli's version of Rhapsody put out one of my favourite albums of 2015 in 'Prometheus'. 

Also I agree with you on Megadeth. I always preferred them over Metallica. The melodic goodness of Megadeth is hard to beat. Personally I think 'Youthanasia' is one of the all time underrated albums, and a release that basically outline how good melodic metal should sound. 

 

7 minutes ago, salmonellapancake said:

1. Death

2. Mercyful Fate

3. King Diamond 

4. Inquisition

5. Slayer

Mercyful Fate AND King Diamond??!! You'd better not get sick of them on your island hahaha.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am gonna be that irritating bastard who takes forever to think up his list to the point where I post entries one at a time (being the fucking master of suspense that I am like)!

First entry is Bolt Thrower as in terms of consistency you'd struggle to find many Death Metal bands with a rack of discs like Bolt Thrower's.  I can only think of one that isn't particularly level with the rest of their output and that is "Mercenary".  Granted that collection of b-sides that the tossers at Earache released against the band's wishes sucked too but I am willing to discount that one on the grounds it is an unofficial release.

Bolt Thrower always have that BIG sound on their records, it is to me Death Metal that surrounds you and makes you feel empowered as a listener which is what good music should do to you.  Great band that are sadly missed but deserve a nod for acknowledging that the stuff they had penned to follow up "Those Once Loyal" was pants and would not be committed to record.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting discussion.... I'm torn between my favourite bands with limited outputs versus those who may not quite be that but who's overall catalogue is sufficient in breadth & scope to provide a lifetime of listening... In no particular order other than the order they popped into my head I would probably 'settle' for:

Thrash: for overall sustained quality and weight of material it would be a toss-up between SODOM and OVERKILL. Neither may have hit the 'absolute highs' of say Megadeth or Metallica, but I'd rate their overall output higher as a 'whole'. I'm gonna say SODOM.

Trad/Heavy Metal perspective: again it's a toss-up between Maiden, Accept, Primal Fear or Running Wild. This is a hard one... Can I contemplate a life with no Fast As a Shark or Balls to the Wall? I guess so. A life without 'freewheel Rider', 'Bad to the Bone' or 'Death or Glory'? I suppose I could... Or no 'King for a Day and 'Never Pray for Justice'. I think ultimately Iron Maiden's vast catalogue plus the pure quality of the first decade wins the day. How could life go on with no 'Hallowed Be Thy Name' or 'The Trooper'?

The 3rd catalogue I would take could be controversial but damn it's my desert and my island so if you don't like my music - stay away...

I'm taking W.A.S.P.

Yes, the great chainsaw codpiece wearer makes the list. Say what you will but 30+ years and a varied catalogue consisting of the great debut, Headless Children, Last Command, Golgotha, Crimson Idol, Double Live Assassins and so forth. Yep I'm happy with this...lots of material and even the crap (looking at you Kill/Fuck/Die and Helldorado) have some quality songs in there.

For my 4th choice I'm leaning towards Saxon or Priest but given the Maiden fix I've already stashed, I might need something a little more varied so I'm taking PARADISE LOST. Everything from death/ doom/Gothic and even (gulp) electronic influences in this grand catalogue. The past 3-4 releases almost represent the 'best' of all their sounds rolled into one. Icon, Draconian Times, In Requiem, The Plague Within, Gothic, Shades of God.... Enough said. The miserable ones it is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Finally I recognise the need for something a bit more extreme on my list - and looking at my collection do I go with Cradle of Filth? Dark Tranquillity? Agalloch? Inquisition? Anathema? King Diamond? Hypocrisy? All would be worthy additions.... But no, if I was to be honest with myself, I'm gonna have to go with....well something that's not extreme at all....

KISS. Too much to pass up, too many good albums and songs. Love Gun, Destroyer, Rock n Roll Over, KISS, Alive 1 and Alive 2, Revenge, Lick It Up, Unmasked, Creatures of the Night, Animalise, Sonic Boom....Ace Frehley Solo Album. Given I'm gonna (presumably) die on this island I could also take one of those KISS Koffins Gene Simmons is so fond of trying to sell...

So that's it folks, I'm done (see Macabre it's not THAT hard..]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, True Belief said:

 

So that's it folks, I'm done (see Macabre it's not THAT hard..]

I was with you right up until Paradise Lost and then you killed our desert island liaison with KISS. The thought of spending a lifetime with you, isolated from humanity with your tongue permanently out air bassing to "Crazy Nights" whilst also having to constantly be on my guard to stop you painting a star over one of my eyes whilst I sleep and reminding you my name isn't Paul is not tickling my fancy.

WASP was a brilliant call though. As was Sodom.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 29/12/2016 at 6:36 PM, MacabreEternal said:

I was with you right up until Paradise Lost and then you killed our desert island liaison with KISS. The thought of spending a lifetime with you, isolated from humanity with your tongue permanently out air bassing to "Crazy Nights" whilst also having to constantly be on my guard to stop you painting a star over one of my eyes whilst I sleep and reminding you my name isn't Paul is not tickling my fancy.

WASP was a brilliant call though. As was Sodom.

Some huge surprises here, True Belief, but a perfect list in the spirit of the islands. Plenty of variety and large back catalogues. 

Imagine listening to Kiss on a deserted island. Surreal.

On 29/12/2016 at 10:10 AM, True Belief said:

Finally I recognise the need for something a bit more extreme on my list - and looking at my collection do I go with Cradle of Filth? Dark Tranquillity? Agalloch? Inquisition? Anathema? King Diamond? Hypocrisy? All would be worthy additions.... But no, if I was to be honest with myself, I'm gonna have to go with....well something that's not extreme at all....

KISS. Too much to pass up, too many good albums and songs. Love Gun, Destroyer, Rock n Roll Over, KISS, Alive 1 and Alive 2, Revenge, Lick It Up, Unmasked, Creatures of the Night, Animalise, Sonic Boom....Ace Frehley Solo Album. Given I'm gonna (presumably) die on this island I could also take one of those KISS Koffins Gene Simmons is so fond of trying to sell...

So that's it folks, I'm done (see Macabre it's not THAT hard..]

Meant to quote you, True Belief....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 29/12/2016 at 6:36 PM, MacabreEternal said: I was with you right up until Paradise Lost and then you killed our desert island liaison with KISS. The thought of spending a lifetime with you, isolated from humanity with your tongue permanently out air bassing to "Crazy Nights" whilst also having to constantly be on my guard to stop you painting a star over one of my eyes whilst I sleep and reminding you my name isn't Paul is not tickling my fancy.

WASP was a brilliant call though. As was Sodom.

Some huge surprises here, True Belief, but a perfect list in the spirit of the islands. Plenty of variety and large back catalogues. 

Imagine listening to Kiss on a deserted island. Surreal.

On 29/12/2016 at 10:10 AM, True Belief said: Finally I recognise the need for something a bit more extreme on my list - and looking at my collection do I go with Cradle of Filth? Dark Tranquillity? Agalloch? Inquisition? Anathema? King Diamond? Hypocrisy? All would be worthy additions.... But no, if I was to be honest with myself, I'm gonna have to go with....well something that's not extreme at all....

KISS. Too much to pass up, too many good albums and songs. Love Gun, Destroyer, Rock n Roll Over, KISS, Alive 1 and Alive 2, Revenge, Lick It Up, Unmasked, Creatures of the Night, Animalise, Sonic Boom....Ace Frehley Solo Album. Given I'm gonna (presumably) die on this island I could also take one of those KISS Koffins Gene Simmons is so fond of trying to sell...

So that's it folks, I'm done (see Macabre it's not THAT hard..]

Meant to quote you, True Belief....

I could listen to KISS anywhere.

It's hard because you end up excluding some favourite bands for others who's catalogues offer more scope and variety.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, True Belief said:

I could listen to KISS anywhere.

It's hard because you end up excluding some favourite bands for others who's catalogues offer more scope and variety.....

Correct, and that's the genius of this thread. 

Solid gold internetting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Death - flawless discography with plenty of variety

Enslaved - near flawless discography with the wintry vibe to trick me into thinking it's cold on that desert island

Bathory - varied and near flawless discography

Black Sabbath - Ozzy era 'nuff said

Pink Floyd - isn't it obvious?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 12/01/2017 at 1:45 PM, RelentlessOblivion said:

Death - flawless discography with plenty of variety

Enslaved - near flawless discography with the wintry vibe to trick me into thinking it's cold on that desert island

Bathory - varied and near flawless discography

Black Sabbath - Ozzy era 'nuff said

Pink Floyd - isn't it obvious?

This is pretty good - there's a lot of variety here. I'd be pretty happy being marooned on an island with these back catalogues. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 29/12/2016 at 0:10 AM, True Belief said:

 

 

 

 

Finally I recognise the need for something a bit more extreme on my list - and looking at my collection do I go with Cradle of Filth? Dark Tranquillity? Agalloch? Inquisition? Anathema? King Diamond? Hypocrisy? All would be worthy additions.... But no, if I was to be honest with myself, I'm gonna have to go with....well something that's not extreme at all....

 

 

 

 

KISS. Too much to pass up, too many good albums and songs. Love Gun, Destroyer, Rock n Roll Over, KISS, Alive 1 and Alive 2, Revenge, Lick It Up, Unmasked, Creatures of the Night, Animalise, Sonic Boom....Ace Frehley Solo Album. Given I'm gonna (presumably) die on this island I could also take one of those KISS Koffins Gene Simmons is so fond of trying to sell...

 

 

 

 

So that's it folks, I'm done (see Macabre it's not THAT hard..]

YESSS!!! Kiss has a shitload of cool records.

What would I do? I'd cheat. I'd say I'd go with the Deep Purple extended family back catalogue. They have liens with any band I love. For instance, this would allow me to sneak ManOwaR and KISS and Twisted Sister.

ManOwaR were formed when Dio introduced Ross The Boss to Joey De Maio, who was then a technician for Black Sabbath. Black Sabbath definitely belongs to the extended Deep Purple family (via the Dio-Blackmore-Rainbow connection, the Gillan-connection and the Glenn Hughes-connection). Once you get Black Sabbath into the picture you can throw Kiss into the family via the Eric Singer-connection. You can throw Alice Cooper via the very same connection. You can throw Queen, still because of Eric Singer but also because of May guesting on "When Death Calls" by Black Sabbath. You can throw Anthrax into the fold via Dave Spitz being the brother of Dan Spitz. Once you have Anthrax you can go back to ManOwaR, because Ross the Boss produced Anthrax! Seriously, you can pick ANY relevant band using Deep Purple connections at large.

Judas Priest! Roger Glover produced "Sin After Sin", so they belong. Halford sung for Black Sabbath, so they belong even more.

Led Zeppelin... Blackmore and Page shared the same guitar instructor and both played with Screaming Lord Sutch. It's a never ending game.

It feels good to be on an island with all my records. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Skull_Kollektor said:

YESSS!!! Kiss has a shitload of cool records.

What would I do? I'd cheat. I'd say I'd go with the Deep Purple extended family back catalogue. They have liens with any band I love. For instance, this would allow me to sneak ManOwaR and KISS and Twisted Sister.

ManOwaR were formed when Dio introduced Ross The Boss to Joey De Maio, who was then a technician for Black Sabbath. Black Sabbath definitely belongs to the extended Deep Purple family (via the Dio-Blackmore-Rainbow connection, the Gillan-connection and the Glenn Hughes-connection). Once you get Black Sabbath into the picture you can throw Kiss into the family via the Eric Singer-connection. You can throw Alice Cooper via the very same connection. You can throw Queen, still because of Eric Singer but also because of May guesting on "When Death Calls" by Black Sabbath. You can throw Anthrax into the fold via Dave Spitz being the brother of Dan Spitz. Once you have Anthrax you can go back to ManOwaR, because Ross the Boss produced Anthrax! Seriously, you can pick ANY relevant band using Deep Purple connections at large.

Judas Priest! Roger Glover produced "Sin After Sin", so they belong. Halford sung for Black Sabbath, so they belong even more.

Led Zeppelin... Blackmore and Page shared the same guitar instructor and both played with Screaming Lord Sutch. It's a never ending game.

It feels good to be on an island with all my records. 

I hope the desert island gods aren't deceived by your sophistry! :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 4/13/2017 at 7:48 AM, Skull_Kollektor said:

YESSS!!! Kiss has a shitload of cool records.

What would I do? I'd cheat. I'd say I'd go with the Deep Purple extended family back catalogue. They have liens with any band I love. For instance, this would allow me to sneak ManOwaR and KISS and Twisted Sister.

ManOwaR were formed when Dio introduced Ross The Boss to Joey De Maio, who was then a technician for Black Sabbath. Black Sabbath definitely belongs to the extended Deep Purple family (via the Dio-Blackmore-Rainbow connection, the Gillan-connection and the Glenn Hughes-connection). Once you get Black Sabbath into the picture you can throw Kiss into the family via the Eric Singer-connection. You can throw Alice Cooper via the very same connection. You can throw Queen, still because of Eric Singer but also because of May guesting on "When Death Calls" by Black Sabbath. You can throw Anthrax into the fold via Dave Spitz being the brother of Dan Spitz. Once you have Anthrax you can go back to ManOwaR, because Ross the Boss produced Anthrax! Seriously, you can pick ANY relevant band using Deep Purple connections at large.

Judas Priest! Roger Glover produced "Sin After Sin", so they belong. Halford sung for Black Sabbath, so they belong even more.

Led Zeppelin... Blackmore and Page shared the same guitar instructor and both played with Screaming Lord Sutch. It's a never ending game.

It feels good to be on an island with all my records. 

Well, if we're going to cheat like that, I could say that I'm taking the "extended family" of Joe Satriani.

Through his pupils alone, I would get Stevie Vai, Possesed, Exodus, Metallica and Testament (Joe himself and Testament would probably have made my list anyway). On top of this I would get the catalogs of the artists associated with G3 and Chickenfoot (Van Halen, Red Hot Chilli Peppers) and Dream Theater (spoken lyrics on Repentance). Among many other connections I could make through Satrianis countless other collaborations (I love Wikipedia)

Plus as he has toured as lead guitar for Deep Purple, I would steal all of your connections.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Will said:

Well, if we're going to cheat like that, I could say that I'm taking the "extended family" of Joe Satriani.

Through his pupils alone, I would get Stevie Vai, Possesed, Exodus, Metallica and Testament (Joe himself and Testament would probably have made my list anyway). On top of this I would get the catalogs of the artists associated with G3 and Chickenfoot (Van Halen, Red Hot Chilli Peppers) and Dream Theater (spoken lyrics on Repentance). Among many other connections I could make through Satrianis countless other collaborations (I love Wikipedia)

Plus as he has toured as lead guitar for Deep Purple, I would steal all of your connections.

You see? It's the Deep Purple thing! The whole heavy metal universe revolves around Deep Purple.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If we're going to cheat I'm going to take Hellhammer (as in Jan Axel Blomberg). 

This means a significant number of albums from: 

Mayhem

Arcturus

Dimmu Borgir

Covenant

Winds

Shining

Thorns

and many others! They're not all brilliant, I grant you, but music is music when you're stuck on a desert island. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Join Metal Forum

    joinus-home.jpg

  • Your Ad Here
    Support the forum, get a special badge and promote yourself to thousands of Metal fans. Click the above link to get started!
  • Our picks

    • https://www.metalforum.com/blogs/entry/50-queensryche-the-verdict/
      • Reputation Points

      • 0 replies

    • https://www.metalforum.com/blogs/entry/48-candlemass-the-door-to-doom/
      • Reputation Points

      • 0 replies
    • Full length number 19 from overkill certainly makes a splash in the energy stakes, I mean there's some modern thrash bands that are a good two decades younger than Overkill who can only hope to achieve the levels of spunk that New Jersey's finest produce here.  That in itself is an achievement, for a band of Overkill's stature and reputation to be able to still sound relevant four decades into their career is no mean feat.  Even in the albums weaker moments it never gets redundant and the energy levels remain high.  There's a real sense of a band in a state of some renewed vigour, helped in no small part by the addition of Jason Bittner on drums.  The former Flotsam & Jetsam skinsman is nothing short of superb throughout "The Wings of War" and seems to have squeezed a little extra out of the rest of his peers.

      The album kicks of with a great build to opening track "Last Man Standing" and for the first 4 tracks of the album the Overkill crew stomp, bash and groove their way to a solid level of consistency.  The lead work is of particular note and Blitz sounds as sneery and scathing as ever.  The album is well produced and mixed too with all parts of the thrash machine audible as the five piece hammer away at your skull with the usual blend of chugging riffs and infectious anthems.  


      There are weak moments as mentioned but they are more a victim of how good the strong tracks are.  In it's own right "Distortion" is a solid enough - if not slightly varied a journey from the last offering - but it just doesn't stand up well against a "Bat Shit Crazy" or a "Head of a Pin".  As the album draws to a close you get the increasing impression that the last few tracks are rescued really by some great solos and stomping skin work which is a shame because trimming of a couple of tracks may have made this less obvious. 

      4/5
      • Reputation Points

      • 0 replies
    • It is fair to say that the Greek stalwarts of the Black Metal scene now have a sound that rarely ventures into the territory so well tread on "Thy Mighty Contract" and "Non Serviam" but it is also fair to say that "The Heretics" sounds from start to finish like a band who firmly stamp themselves on the metal map for 2019.  What album number thirteen from Rotting Christ does is take a measured approach to variation and repetition to build a memorable and lasting experience.

      The sound itself goes from dark and brooding metal and hard rock to almost Gothic metal proportions.  Yet at the same time that familiar melodic warmth remains in situ throughout.  More often than not there's that big soaring melodic riff riding the vocals like a surfer with his board.  "The Voice of the Universe" does this superbly as does "The Sons of Hell".  The overall feel the record as a whole leaves me with is one of ritualistic allure, tracks like "Hallowed Be Thy Name" and "Fire God and Fear" build well like powerful incantations being cited from voluminous tomes, flooding forwards intermittently with flowing dark melodies.


      It does remind me a lot of Behemoth ("The Satanist" Behemoth, not last years pompous bollocks Behemoth), with the theme of religion so heavily referenced but at the same time it feels like a much more cohesive effort than recent Behemoth keeping a level of consistency and restraint to the songwriting which holds the attention well.  Only once does the album visit anything like Black Metal on "I Believe", here they base a poem by Nikolaos Kazantzakis at the centre of the chaotic and frantic pace and sadly it fails miserably on my ears, coming across as just filler.  My only other criticism is that it does get a bit samey in places (namely the intros to each track).  Otherwise it is a perfectly respectable piece of dark metal.  C'mon, we can't this black metal anymore folks.

       

      3/5
      • Reputation Points

      • 0 replies
    • So here I am reviewing the new Drudkh album...oh...wait a minute...no apparently it isn't Drudkh, it is Windswept.  A quick look on the internet tells me that Windswept are Drudkh minus keyboards in terms of members.  Therefore Windswept is just a less atmospheric version of Drudkh?  That's not really a question as I have heard "The Onlooker" and I know it is in fact a statement of truth.

      I don't get it.  If I want to hear a Drudkh record I will just put one on.  Similarly, if I was a member of Drudkh and I wanted to make a new record, I'd just pick up the phone to my bandmates and start the writing process.  The fact that the majority of the band have made a different band just to not have atmosphere seems a little grandiose to me, although I get that the stylistic integrity of Drudkh is maintained. 

      It isn't that the album is bad.  Perfectly solid and driving, melodic BM cleverly framed by a music box intro and outro is what you get here folks.  It just sounds so much like Drudkh I can't get my head around the fact that it is just a below par Drudkh offering.  The one thing the record is crying out for is some atmosphere - THE FUCKING IRONY!


      If you can forget the existence of a Ukranian BM band called Drudkh, or perhaps have just been born into the world of BM and have no previous concept of the 3 band members here being involved in anything else then you will no doubt easily spot the merits of "The Onlooker".  For me it served no other purpose than to give me a really short review to write this week (and to put some Drudkh on).

      Based on it's merit as a standalone album = 3/5

      Hideously critical mind of a Drudkh fan rating = 2/5
      • Reputation Points

      • 0 replies
×
×
  • Create New...