Jump to content
Sign in to stalk this  
Requiem

Top 10 Gothic Metal Albums

Recommended Posts

This sort of thing is all the rage at the moment on the forums and is sorely lacking here.

Here is my top 10, following the one album per band rule. If a band straddles the doom or black genres I've gone with an album that (sort of) fits the gothic metal genre. @Vampyrique I've updated and filled out my list. 

 

10a. Sirenia - 'Perils of the Deep Blue' (2013)

Morten Veland's project has now really become his main event, with many more Sirenia albums now in existence compared with his Tristania work. This album is arguably my favourite of the Sirenia material. It has an epic scale but it's catchy and engaging all the way through, with a phat yet luscious production. This is the second last yet best album he would record with Ailyn on vocals. She has such a special voice. 

10b. To/Die/For - 'Jaded' (2003)

This is from the rock side of the genre. To/Die/For were untouchable for catchy melodic music around this era, and this album is just brilliant. Jape's deep voice was in its prime and the songs here are all gothic rock anthems. 

9. Saturnus - 'Martyre' (1999)

The final release from the Kim Larsen lineup of Saturnus, this album begins with the beautiful choir of '7' before launching into one of gothic metal's most exquisite moments with that riff from 'Inflame Thy Heart'. This album is just full of near perfect riffs and near perfect vocals with the spoken word, mid range bark and full deep growl. Spinetingling. 

8. Moonspell - 'Irreligious' (1996)

We are now officially in masterpiece territory. This is one of many classics from the 90s as you can see from the list. Tracks like 'Opium' and 'Full Moon Madness' are timeless. 

7. Tristania - 'Widow's Weeds' (1998)

A true gothic album, this contains choirs, creaking church doors, organs and some incredible metal. Morten Veland's second appearance on the list. That guy is a genius. I went with this, their debut, over the more upbeat 'Beyond the Veil' because this has the real ivy-on-manor-house-walls feel that perfectly sums up the genre. 

6. Theatre of Tragedy - 'Aegis' (1998)

I was so tempted to put 'Velvet Darkness They Fear' in this spot rather than 'Aegis', but I think 'Aegis' just wins out due to some nice memories of a girl from university who used to like listening to this when we were being intimate. The band dropped the growls and replaced them with Raymond's dulcet speaking voice, and they amped up the repetitive catchiness and sweetness. What they ended up with was a beautiful album and me getting laid. 

5. My Dying Bride - 'Like Gods of the Sun' (1996)

This album really changed my life. Technically I would class 'The Angel and the Dark River' as gothic metal as well, and on a good day I prefer that album, but this album just fits the vibe of gothic metal so perfectly. When I first heard the title track on Australian radio back in 96 I knew I'd found the next level. This is dark with fabulous twin guitar harmonies and a great violin sound back when it was still original. Oh man I love this album. 

4. Paradise Lost - 'Draconian Times' (1995)

Paradise Lost are responsible for so much in this genre. This album is nearly perfect in its production, artwork, texture and sophistication. When I discovered this album back in about early 1996 I thought this band was the classiest metal band I'd ever come across. 

3. Cradle of Filth - 'Dusk and Her Embrace' (1996)

Writing out these little reviews is bringing home how important this genre is to me. Cradle's 'Dusk' album is a theatrical masterpiece. Romantic keyboards, epic soundscapes, beautiful gothic riffs and some of Dani's best lyrics. Amazing artwork too. 

2. Anathema - 'Alternative 4' (1998)

Is this gothic metal? It's close enough and I'm running with it. The violin, piano and mournful guitar riffs all work on crushing the heart with some of Vincent's best vocal lines and Duncan Patterson's best lyrics. Yes, 'Fragile Dreams' and 'Inner Silence' are well recognised classics, but check out 'Lost Control' and 'Feel' for crying out loud. Just amazing. I used to have 'Feel' on a tape that I had recorded from the radio back in 1998. God, what an era. 

1. Type O Negative - 'October Rust' (1996)

And here's number 1. This isn't just my favourite gothic metal album of all time (which is bloody saying something, let me tell you), but it's also probably my favourite album of all time of any genre (if that's even possible to call). Peter Steele and Josh Silver are just so far beyond the rest of the planet on this album that it's hard to believe it was created by humans. Songs like 'Love you to Death', 'Red Water (Christmas Mourning', 'Wolf Moon' and 'Haunted' are untouchable. 'Be My Druidess' has one of the greatest ending riff/vocal lines of all time. Everything about this album is romantic, emotional and gothic. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 20/03/2017 at 9:15 AM, BlutAusNerd said:

Interesting. I don't listen to a ton of gothic metal, but I would like to dig through my collection for research and participate in this.

 

Sent from my HTC6535LVW using Tapatalk

 

 

That would be cool. I would really be interested to see what people who weren't into the genre listed as their favourites. That would take some digging, but I'm sure most in the internet age could cobble together a list, even if they were least worsts!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gothic metal is ****** sensational and with the many bands, there is something for everyone. Really doesn't matter if you love extream death metal like I do. I am sure you will also love symphonic and gothic metal like I worship.

I love bands like Xandria, Therion, Metalwings etc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, TheDemonicWoman said:

Gothic metal is ****** sensational and with the many bands, there is something for everyone. Really doesn't matter if you love extream death metal like I do. I am sure you will also love symphonic and gothic metal like I worship.

I love bands like Xandria, Therion, Metalwings etc

Nice post! Therion are awesome, especially the 'Theli' and 'Vovin' albums. They were part of that great 90s scene. Who else are you into? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I nearly had a nibble there but the user got away. I'll cast the line out again and just wait... biding my time... ready to talk gothic metal at the first sign of a bite. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Requiem said:

Haha, lucky as a sad goth the loneliness suits me... 

When I finally get my list together, you'll be able to remove your wrist that had ages past been cemented in eternal mourning to your brow and proclaim that you're no longer alone... 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 hours ago, BlutAusNerd said:

When I finally get my list together, you'll be able to remove your wrist that had ages past been cemented in eternal mourning to your brow and proclaim that you're no longer alone... 

One of the hardest things in creating a list of gothic metal is to figure out what is actually gothic metal and not simply romantic doom, or darkened pop metal, or symphonic melodic metal. In the end I just went with albums and bands that gave me the gothic vibe, had forlorn lyrical topics, maybe a violin or two. To paraphrase Fenriz: "Gothic metal isn't about one sound, it's about a feeling you get". 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, Requiem said:

One of the hardest things in creating a list of gothic metal is to figure out what is actually gothic metal and not simply romantic doom, or darkened pop metal, or symphonic melodic metal. In the end I just went with albums and bands that gave me the gothic vibe, had forlorn lyrical topics, maybe a violin or two. To paraphrase Fenriz: "Gothic metal isn't about one sound, it's about a feeling you get". 

I don't think it's so much that as that Gothic metal has a lot of crossover with other metal styles. Gothic black metal, Gothic doom, Gothic/symphonic metal, etc... you just don't hear of a lot of it that stands on its own. Sort of like how speed metal is often found as power/speed metal, speed/thrash metal, heavy/speed metal, but seldom just as speed metal. Kind of an interesting concept I guess. I'm sure my list will have lots of those combinations in it, but I think even I'll be surprised at how it actually shakes out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, BlutAusNerd said:

I don't think it's so much that as that Gothic metal has a lot of crossover with other metal styles. Gothic black metal, Gothic doom, Gothic/symphonic metal, etc... you just don't hear of a lot of it that stands on its own. Sort of like how speed metal is often found as power/speed metal, speed/thrash metal, heavy/speed metal, but seldom just as speed metal. Kind of an interesting concept I guess. I'm sure my list will have lots of those combinations in it, but I think even I'll be surprised at how it actually shakes out.

I think that's pretty much what I was saying. I like the idea that we're being somewhat liberal with genre boundaries for gothic metal. I know how much it pains you to see a band mislabelled by genre ;) 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Requiem said:

I think that's pretty much what I was saying. I like the idea that we're being somewhat liberal with genre boundaries for gothic metal. I know how much it pains you to see a band mislabelled by genre ;) 

Indeed it does. Believe it or not, I'm even more pedantic in person. ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, BlutAusNerd said:

Indeed it does. Believe it or not, I'm even more pedantic in person. ?

I've heard people call Children of Bodom 'black metal'. I'll steer you clear of them...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I kept the same criteria as Requiem: one album per band, otherwise it would likely be dominated by two bands. And I use 'gothic' as a descriptor rather than the common genre definition. I provided some brief notes for each album. This is only a rough idea of my top ten as it is hard to include only ten.  

 

Theatres des Vampires - Bloody Lunatic Asylum

An absolute masterpiece. TdV really had something special going on in the late 90s/early 00s before they changed their direction and split with their vocalist. 

 

Cradle of Filth - The Principle of Evil Made Flesh

It's brutal, ugly, and utterly atmospheric in its funereal gloom. One of many masterpieces that the band has released. 

 

Darkness of Blood - A Dream of Vampires in Astral Dementia

It doesn't get any more vampiric than this obscure masterpiece, trust me. This is a blood overdose.   

 

My Dying Bride - As the Flower Withers

Whist essentially being a death metal album, it does display some gothic touches here and there. Some of their later albums may wear the descriptor better but, nevertheless, this is my personal favourite of theirs.  

 

Dimmu Borgir - Spiritual Black Dimensions

I normally wouldn't refer to Dimmu Borgir as gothic but this particular album is. I think this was due to the changes in line-up and it's no surprise that it is very similar to Mirrored Hate Painting, only more majestic. 

 

Moonspell - Wolfheart

I have a difficult time choosing between this and Irreligious but I think I prefer Wolfheart stylistically.  

 

Deinonychus - The Weeping of a Thousand Years

An anomaly amid their catalogue, Deinonychus decided to fully immerse themselves in gothic atmospheres on this album. 

 

Evenfall - Still in the Grey Dying

Excellent album, similar to early Theatres des Vampires.  

 

Anathema - The Silent Enigma

Excellent album, more engaging than their debut. I prefer earlier Anathema over their later stuff. 

 

Paradise Lost - Icon

I am not entirely sure this is my favourite of theirs but Icon, along with Gothic and Draconian Times, represents Paradise Lost at their best. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 hours ago, Vampyrique said:

I kept the same criteria as Requiem: one album per band, otherwise it would likely be dominated by two bands. And I use 'gothic' as a descriptor rather than the common genre definition. I provided some brief notes for each album. This is only a rough idea of my top ten as it is hard to include only ten.  

 

Theatres des Vampires - Bloody Lunatic Asylum

An absolute masterpiece. TdV really had something special going on in the late 90s/early 00s before they changed their direction and split with their vocalist. 

 

Cradle of Filth - The Principle of Evil Made Flesh

It's brutal, ugly, and utterly atmospheric in its funereal gloom. One of many masterpieces that the band has released. 

 

Darkness of Blood - A Dream of Vampires in Astral Dementia

It doesn't get any more vampiric than this obscure masterpiece, trust me. This is a blood overdose.   

 

My Dying Bride - As the Flower Withers

Whist essentially being a death metal album, it does display some gothic touches here and there. Some of their later albums may wear the descriptor better but, nevertheless, this is my personal favourite of theirs.  

 

Dimmu Borgir - Spiritual Black Dimensions

I normally wouldn't refer to Dimmu Borgir as gothic but this particular album is. I think this was due to the changes in line-up and it's no surprise that it is very similar to Mirrored Hate Painting, only more majestic. 

 

Moonspell - Wolfheart

I have a difficult time choosing between this and Irreligious but I think I prefer Wolfheart stylistically.  

 

Deinonychus - The Weeping of a Thousand Years

An anomaly amid their catalogue, Deinonychus decided to fully immerse themselves in gothic atmospheres on this album. 

 

Evenfall - Still in the Grey Dying

Excellent album, similar to early Theatres des Vampires.  

 

Anathema - The Silent Enigma

Excellent album, more engaging than their debut. I prefer earlier Anathema over their later stuff. 

 

Paradise Lost - Icon

I am not entirely sure this is my favourite of theirs but Icon, along with Gothic and Draconian Times, represents Paradise Lost at their best. 

 

Awesome choices. There are a couple there that I'm not familiar with and will have to check out. 

I have to say, I'm surprised to see one of the first couple of albums from Theatre of Tragedy and Tristania missing. Are you into these albums? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I remember thinking early Theatre of tragedy was ok but not really my thing. I like Tristania but I only own their debut Widow's Weeds and I'm not too familiar with them beyond their early albums. 

My list is a rough idea my top ten, and it is partial to my tastes in music in general. It wasn't really meant to be an ideal representation of gothic metal; rather, it was my favourite albums that tangentially or directly fall within the scope of gothic when used as a descriptor. There are many albums that I could have included but it is hard to narrow it down to ten. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 13/08/2017 at 0:30 PM, Vampyrique said:

I remember thinking early Theatre of tragedy was ok but not really my thing. I like Tristania but I only own their debut Widow's Weeds and I'm not too familiar with them beyond their early albums. 

My list is a rough idea my top ten, and it is partial to my tastes in music in general. It wasn't really meant to be an ideal representation of gothic metal; rather, it was my favourite albums that tangentially or directly fall within the scope of gothic when used as a descriptor. There are many albums that I could have included but it is hard to narrow it down to ten. 

I updated this thread because I wanted to explain my choices better. Plus I remembered that I'd forgotten Saturnus which I feel really does fit the gothic metal framework that I'm working in just as much they do a doom one. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Requiem said:

I updated this thread because I wanted to explain my choices better. Plus I remembered that I'd forgotten Saturnus which I feel really does fit the gothic metal framework that I'm working in just as much they do a doom one. 

Martyre is definitely a Gothic metal album, it doesn't have much to do with doom at all. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My top 10 Gothic Metal Albums

1 Tristania - Widow's Weeds

2 The Sins of Thy Beloved - Lake of Sorrow

3 The Gathering - Mandylion

4 Tristania - Beyond The Veil

5 Sirenia - An Elixir For Existance

6 Draconian - Sovran

7 Trail of Tears - Disclosure in Red

8 Sirenia - At Sixes And Sevens

9 The Gathering - Always...

10 Theatre of Tragedy - Theatre of Tragedy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Earendel said:

My top 10 Gothic Metal Albums

1 Tristania - Widow's Weeds

2 The Sins of Thy Beloved - Lake of Sorrow

3 The Gathering - Mandylion

4 Tristania - Beyond The Veil

5 Sirenia - An Elixir For Existance

6 Draconian - Sovran

7 Trail of Tears - Disclosure in Red

8 Sirenia - At Sixes And Sevens

9 The Gathering - Always...

10 Theatre of Tragedy - Theatre of Tragedy

Excellent list!

'Lake of Sorrow' is really high here. I really need to finally buy this. I couldn't find a new copy on ebay so maybe I'll try discogs. Interesting to see both classic Tristania albums but only Theatre of Tragedy's debut creeping in at number 10. Great to see another Sirenia fan. I see you lean towards their early few albums, which I also love, although I do prefer their two of their last three.

Love your number 1! 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Requiem said:

Excellent list!

'Lake of Sorrow' is really high here. I really need to finally buy this. I couldn't find a new copy on ebay so maybe I'll try discogs. Interesting to see both classic Tristania albums but only Theatre of Tragedy's debut creeping in at number 10. Great to see another Sirenia fan. I see you lean towards their early few albums, which I also love, although I do prefer their two of their last three.

Love your number 1! 

Thank you!  I found Lake of Sorrow and Perpetual Desolation  available in CD format on amazon. I love Theatre of Tragedy's first three albums. Albums released after Aegis are not for me. They're have too much electronic influences. Not my cup of tea. Tristania is my beloved gothic metal band. I simply adore Widow's Weeds and Beyond The Veil! I think Widow's Weeds is essence of gothic metal. To be honest I love all Tristania albums with Vibeke on vocals. I miss her so much. I really like Sirenia. Especially their two first albums as you can see. Also Perils of The Deep Blue and The Seventh Life Path are amazing :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with you 100% on all of this! All the opinions you’ve posted are mine too. 

If you haven’t already, check out the latest Sirenia album ‘Dim Days of Dolor’. It could almost be my favourite of theirs.

And yes, the first three Theatre of Tragedy and the Vibeke Tristania albums (especially the first two) are stunning!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to stalk this  

  • Join Metal Forum

    joinus-home.jpg

  • Your Ad Here
    Support the forum, get a special badge and promote yourself to thousands of Metal fans. Click the above link to get started!
  • Our picks

    • So here I am reviewing the new Drudkh album...oh...wait a minute...no apparently it isn't Drudkh, it is Windswept.  A quick look on the internet tells me that Windswept are Drudkh minus keyboards in terms of members.  Therefore Windswept is just a less atmospheric version of Drudkh?  That's not really a question as I have heard "The Onlooker" and I know it is in fact a statement of truth.

      I don't get it.  If I want to hear a Drudkh record I will just put one on.  Similarly, if I was a member of Drudkh and I wanted to make a new record, I'd just pick up the phone to my bandmates and start the writing process.  The fact that the majority of the band have made a different band just to not have atmosphere seems a little grandiose to me, although I get that the stylistic integrity of Drudkh is maintained. 

      It isn't that the album is bad.  Perfectly solid and driving, melodic BM cleverly framed by a music box intro and outro is what you get here folks.  It just sounds so much like Drudkh I can't get my head around the fact that it is just a below par Drudkh offering.  The one thing the record is crying out for is some atmosphere - THE FUCKING IRONY!


      If you can forget the existence of a Ukranian BM band called Drudkh, or perhaps have just been born into the world of BM and have no previous concept of the 3 band members here being involved in anything else then you will no doubt easily spot the merits of "The Onlooker".  For me it served no other purpose than to give me a really short review to write this week (and to put some Drudkh on).

      Based on it's merit as a standalone album = 3/5

      Hideously critical mind of a Drudkh fan rating = 2/5
      • Reputation Points

      • 0 replies
    • When it comes to death/doom, variety is not necessarily top of the average listener's appeal list.  Usually when I review such a release I find myself typing "doesn't reinvent the wheel but does the genre justice with this solid offering" or words to that effect.  Ossuarium's debut full length falls under that banner most definitely.  Nobody is fucking around here with a saxophone to make the offering standout with some eclectic and unnecessary deviation from tradition.  If you like your death metal doomy or your doom metal deathy then chalk up a tick in your respective box folks!

      Click the link for more:
      https://www.metalforum.com/blogs/entry/44-ossuarium-living-tomb/
      • Reputation Points

      • 0 replies
    • The roar has always been approaching.  As far back as three years ago when Altarage dropped their debut full length 'Nihl', this scribe could already hear the threat of their ability, feel the menace of their presence from over hills far away and sense the nefarious intent as the raw fury howled over my skin...
      • Reputation Points

      • 0 replies
    • There's life in the old dog yet it seems.  It terms of original members only Phil Fasciana remains in the ranks of Malevolent Creation now and after the passing of Brett Hoffman last year you could almost forgive fans for thinking the curtain had fallen on Malevolent Creation.  The fact is that whilst "The 13th Beast" reinvents no wheels it does exhibit the sound of a band in the throes of something of a regeneration phase.  There's nothing tired sounding here, no dull interludes to build unnecessary atmosphere.  As soon as the spoken word intro to "End the Torture" finishes it is straight up thrashing death metal until the very end, some 11 tracks later.

      Although all debuting in the Malevolent full length stakes here, the 3 musicians that join Fasciana on this record are all clearly capable and qualified purveyors of their art form.  Again, I highlight that this is not far above your average DM record yet it is so assured and solid you can easily forgive it to some degree.  Lee Wollenschlaeger gives a good acquittal of himself as an established and competent vocalist, filling Hoffman's shoes nicely.  Phil Cancilla is a machine on those skins, blasting his way across the soundscape yet also using the percussion well when the occasional let up in the pace permits.  Fasciana and Wollenschlaeger work well together to keep the chug of the riffs motoring along whilst Gibbs plonks, twangs and rumbles his way through every track, allowed to be heard in the mix and show his variety without ever showboating.  For a band together for only 2 years as a four piece they sound tight and committed.

      There's no metal fan worth the denim their patches are sewn onto that doesn't look at that album cover and mouth a "fuck me, dude!"  I mean, come on, it is fucking awesome.  Like a more ornamental Predator head on a ghostly green background.  I love it when album covers are matched by the content of the record inside, and whilst there are obviously some shortfalls here, still in the main "The 13th Beast" delivers.  When they keep the track length short and succinct, Malevolent Creation are at their best.  "The Beast Awakened", "Agony for the Chosen" and "Knife at Hand" all kick serious ass.  By the same token "Born of Pain" at nearly 7 minutes long doesn't really do anything or go anywhere to justify the length attributed to it.

      Overall, I would have preferred a shorter record.  At 11 tracks the band cover a lot of ground in under 50 minutes but not all of it really needs treading.  That withstanding, never does it get grating and still the accessibility factor remains consistent enough to forgive the extra excursions present.

      So, having started slowly, January 2019 has finally delivered something worthwhile and a first physical purchase also of a new release for this year.  3/5

       
      • Reputation Points

      • 0 replies
    • Variety is the spice of life, so they say.  Someone might want to mention this to Legion of the Damned.  Picking up right were Venom left off last week in the the generic stakes, "Slaves of the Shadow Realm" churns out a largely unvaried, unremarkable and unmemorable thrash metal with the odd splash of death and black metal smatterings here and there.  To give you some idea of how hard going this is I have to wait three whole tracks to here a lead guitar!  I love good chug fest as much as the next man but when it is the only flavour in the dish its impact on the palette diminishes quickly.

      I can't honestly tell if the album is supposed to be one long song accidentally edited to give gaps to give the illusion of it being several tracks?  Some tracks just start very lazy (Slaves of the Southern Cross) whilst others just allude to some slight break of pace from the previous track before going off on the exact same pace, in the exact same direction (Nocturnal Commando).

      The frustration is that when they get it at least half right and vary things just a touch, they can put together some enjoyable pieces (Warhounds of Hades) but the memorability factor still struggles to register much above a 0, even in these moments.


      By far the pinnacle of the record is "Black Banners in Flames", a menacing thrasher of a track that allows for some relent in the ferocity stakes to apply some melody to create that aforementioned menace.  Otherwise I feel that I have had a sub par meal at a restaurant.  The chefs are perfectly competent (no Michelin stars here though folks) and the ingredients are all of reasonable quality, sourced responsibly enough, but there's little attempt at seasoning and so everything just seems bland.  It sounds like the vocalist is holding this together really.  Swinkels performance on all tracks is obviously a notch up from his band mates' which is a shame because he deserves better really.



      2/5 (2019 is not starting well)
      • Reputation Points

      • 0 replies
×