Re: BestBlackMetalAlbums.com
We are not ranking bands, we are ranking albums, and I can assure you there are no "shit" albums on our Top 100 list, and even though Abigail Williams is in fact a shit band, their last album before splitting up, "Becoming", is not a shit album, and I strongly suggest you check it out and keep an open mind while doing so. We also shared your same point of view regarding this band until being strongly recommended to check out "Becoming" ourselves.
After many "LOL NO DATS SHIT" and "GAY BAND LOL" comments on our behalf, we finally conceded and gave it a shot. It was a very pleasant surprise because it is played in a totally different style compared to their previous garbage, and it's rating perfectly reflects just how impressed we were with the whole thing. As for Abigail Williams' other works, you can clearly see our distaste for their other albums which, as has been stated in the original post, we have included in our database purely for the sake of completion:
http://www.bestblackmetalalbums.com/bes ... albums.php
Abigail Williams' "In The Absence Of Light" is in fact the fourth-lowest scoring album in our entire database, which now contains 1977 albums. In a similar fashion, their other album, "In The Shadow Of A Thousand Suns", is the 23rd lowest scoring album in our database. I hope this fact alone is enough to convince you that we judge individual albums, and not bands (although to be honest we took great pleasure in giving their first two albums such a low score!) Unfortunately we haven't got round to writing a review for any of their albums, but you can observe further evidence for our disliking of their earlier material by reading our news post about their announced disbanding:
http://www.bestblackmetalalbums.com/abi ... _a_day.php
"While we normally wouldn't give a fuck about such a mediocre musical endeavor as Abigail Williams, the truth is that their last album, released on the 24th of January this year and titled Becoming, was actually pretty good and very different from anything the band had done before. "
As for Wolves In The Throne Room, that's a matter of taste I guess... although I am curious as to why you say "WITTR's latest material" when only their first album appears on our Top 100 list.
Lastly and, judging by the degree of your misunderstanding or misinterpretation of exactly how our website works, most importantly, user ratings have absolutely no influence upon the score or ranking of the albums. The user rating system is simply a mechanism for users to express their own opinion about each individual album. Each album's score is decided exclusively by us and us alone, and therefore the list IS a correct representation of OUR favourite albums.
We most certainly did not just "select the albums to be apportioned for voting and that's all"... If you are confused or even offended by encountering a Top 100 list that isn't exclusively composed of second-wave Norwegian classic black metal albums, then we can safely arrive at the conclusion that you should avoid our website at all costs, and should seek trveness elsewhere.